Unpopular Opinion: Cables and Dumbbells BETTER than Barbells and Machines (for Physique)

Prof. Stacks

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
The Benefits of Training with free weights and cables more frequently than barbells and machines involves an understanding of Add a heading (5).pngbiomechanical and physiological advantages that the former equipment provides. Here are the three key points elaborated to support my argument:

1. Enhanced Central Nervous System Activation and Muscle Stabilization: Training with free weights and cables demands a higher level of central nervous system (CNS) activation compared to machines and fixed barbells. This is because free weights and cables require the lifter to control the weight throughout the entire range of motion, engaging not just the primary muscle groups but also the surrounding stabilizing muscles. This comprehensive engagement results in a more effective workout by improving balance, coordination, and overall muscle development. Unlike machines, which often isolate a single muscle or muscle group, free weights and cables mimic natural movement patterns, requiring the body to stabilize itself and manage the weight, thereby maximizing training effectiveness and functional strength.

2. Maximized Time Under Tension: Cables operate on a pulley system, which offers constant resistance throughout the exercise's range of motion. This constant tension keeps the muscles engaged longer, which can lead to increased muscle hypertrophy and strength gains over time. In contrast, machines and some barbell exercises may not provide consistent resistance throughout the entire movement due to the mechanical advantage that changes with the joint angle in different phases of the lift. The continuous resistance offered by cables ensures that muscles are under tension for a longer duration within a single repetition, enhancing the stimulus for growth and strength.

3. Flexibility and Joint Health: Both cables and free weights offer the advantage of a non-fixed bar path, allowing the lifter to adjust their movement pattern according to their individual biomechanics. This adaptability can lead to less wear and tear on the joints, as it enables users to perform exercises in a range of motion that is natural and comfortable for their body, reducing the risk of injury. Furthermore, by not being restricted to a fixed path, lifters can focus the force more directly on the desired muscle groups, optimizing muscle activation and growth. This flexibility in movement patterns is particularly beneficial for engaging in functional training that enhances performance in daily activities and sports, where movements are rarely fixed or isolated.

In conclusion, while barbell and machine-based training can be effective for strength and muscle building, training with free weights and cables offers superior benefits in terms of CNS activation, muscle stabilization, maximized time under tension, flexibility in movement, and joint health. These advantages contribute to a more effective, functional, and sustainable training regimen.
 
Back
Top